Premium Writing, Design & Advisory · Dubai, UAE

ACADEMIC SUPPORT · UAE & GCC

How to Respond to Journal Reviewer Comments: An Evidence-Led Revision Workflow

Turn a difficult decision letter into a traceable revision plan without overstating what your data can prove.

Journal manuscript, reviewer comments and structured response notes
Quick answer

Read the editor’s decision and every reviewer report before changing the manuscript. Create a numbered response matrix, resolve comments against the underlying evidence, revise the manuscript, and write a point-by-point letter showing what changed and where. If a requested change is not justified or feasible, explain the reason respectfully. Follow the target journal’s own revision instructions and deadline.

Receiving “major revision” can feel like a second rejection. It is an invitation to revise, not an acceptance promise. A clear response gives editors a way to verify that you addressed the scientific and editorial questions. The advice below is for researchers responding to peer review of their own work across the UAE and GCC; journal-specific instructions always take priority.

Taylor & Francis Author Services recommends planning changes, marking them in the manuscript and explaining disagreement when warranted. Frontiers’ author guidance likewise treats revision as a dialogue and asks authors to address the editor and reviewers directly. Neither guide provides a universal acceptance formula.

First, separate a decision letter into four kinds of work

Do not answer line by line immediately. A reviewer may repeat another reviewer’s concern, propose an analysis your data cannot support, or ask for a simple wording repair. Sorting first prevents contradictory edits and lets co-authors see where a methodological decision is needed.

Comment type What to check before writing Useful response evidence
Clarity or structure Which sentence, figure or section confused the reader? Revised wording and an exact manuscript location.
Method or analysis Can the data and approved study design answer the request? Analysis rationale, diagnostics, revised results and limitations.
Interpretation Does a claim exceed the result, sampling frame or uncertainty? A narrower conclusion tied to the actual finding.
Journal compliance What do the current author instructions require? Corrected files, declarations, figure format or reference style.

The Northwestern University Writing Place advises making revisions easy to locate and showing new text where useful. That principle is especially valuable when two reviewers give apparently conflicting advice: explain how the revision addresses the shared underlying concern instead of saying only that you “considered” both comments.

Build a response matrix before you edit

Give each substantive comment an identifier, assign an owner, record the planned change and track the exact manuscript location. A simple table becomes the bridge between the revised document and the response letter. Keep the reviewer’s meaning intact when you paraphrase internally; in the final response, quote or reproduce comments as the journal requests.

ID and concern Evidence or decision Manuscript action Response proof
R1.2: Sample selection is unclear. Check the recruitment log and approved protocol. State eligibility, recruitment route and exclusions in Methods. “Methods, page 6, lines 142–157”; use current pagination.
R2.1: Claim sounds causal. Cross-sectional design supports association, not causation. Replace causal wording; explain design limitation. Revised abstract, Discussion and limitations locations.
Editor: Figure labels are hard to read. Check journal specifications and underlying figure file. Regenerate labels without altering plotted values. New figure file and legend location.

This is an illustrative workflow, not a real submission. The page and line references in your letter must point to your final uploaded version. If the portal renumbers pages or strips tracked changes, check the final files again before submitting.

Work through the revision in a defensible order

  1. Read the editor first. The decision letter may elevate a concern or set a condition that takes precedence over a reviewer’s optional suggestion. Record the deadline and file requirements from the portal.
  2. Resolve science before polish. Check design, data, analyses, interpretation and ethics statements before refining prose. A clear sentence cannot repair an unsupported result.
  3. Agree on author decisions. Assign the relevant co-author or statistician to each technical response. Keep the author responsible for the research and final approval.
  4. Revise one master manuscript. Use version control or tracked changes according to the journal’s instructions; avoid parallel files with different findings.
  5. Write the response from the completed revision. State what changed, cite the location and quote a short revised passage if that helps the editor verify it.
  6. Cross-check files. Match every response to the actual manuscript, tables, figures, supplement and declarations that will be uploaded.

For a major request you cannot satisfy, do not quietly omit it. The Icahn School of Medicine’s peer-review guide advises honest explanation when a suggested revision is not possible. Explain the data or design constraint, show any narrower analysis or limitation you added, and ask the editor for guidance when the request affects the paper’s central claim.

Worked example: acknowledge, change, locate

Suppose a reviewer writes: “The conclusion implies the training programme caused improved performance, but the study has no comparison group.” A weak reply says, “We disagree; the programme worked.” That neither resolves the design issue nor helps the editor inspect a revision.

Evidence check

The data show a before-and-after difference in one participating group. Other explanations cannot be excluded without a stronger design.

Manuscript change

Replace “caused improvement” with a descriptive finding; add the lack of a comparison group to limitations.

Response letter

“Thank you. We have narrowed the conclusion to an observed change and added the design limitation in Discussion, page X, lines Y–Z.” Replace X/Y/Z with final locations.

If the reviewer instead requests a new experiment that cannot be completed, give the specific reason, identify what your current data can support and consider whether the main claim must be reduced. A respectful disagreement is different from ignoring the comment. Frontiers explicitly recognises that authors may disagree when they explain their reasoning.

What should the response letter contain?

Open with a short note to the editor, then handle comments in an order the editor can follow. Many journals accept a point-by-point format, but check whether the portal requires a separate letter, response fields, a marked manuscript or a clean manuscript. Keep the tone professional even when a comment seems mistaken.

Part Include Avoid
Opening Manuscript title or ID, thanks and a brief summary of major revisions. Claims that the paper is now certain to be accepted.
Each response Comment identifier, direct answer, action taken and final location. “Done” without a verifiable change.
When disagreeing Evidence-based reason and any narrower wording or limitation. Defensive language or a new unreported analysis.
Closing check Consistency among manuscript, tables, figures, supplements and declarations. Line numbers from an earlier file version.

A peer-reviewed editorial guide recommends numbering major comments to support cross-references. Use that structure to reduce repetition without making the reader hunt for the actual answer.

Final checks before resubmission

  • Does each editor and reviewer concern have an explicit response or a documented reason it cannot be met?
  • Are the revised abstract, results, tables and conclusion consistent with the same data?
  • Do locations and quoted text match the final upload, not a working draft?
  • Have all authors reviewed the scientific changes and approved the version where required?
  • Are journal-specific reporting, ethics, disclosure and file requirements satisfied?
  • Does any external editorial help stay within the journal’s authorship and acknowledgement rules?

The ICMJE recommendations explain author responsibility and accountability for submitted work. They are particularly relevant to medical journals and a useful ethics reference elsewhere, but the selected journal’s own instructions remain the operative submission checklist. Editorial assistance can improve language, structure and traceability; it cannot replace an author’s scientific judgement or guarantee a positive decision.

Your next step

Make your revision easy to verify

If your author-written manuscript and reviewer reports need a clearer response structure, Labeeb can scope ethical manuscript editing, journal-guideline alignment and a response-matrix review. Bring the decision letter, anonymised reviewer comments, current manuscript and target journal’s instructions. You remain responsible for the research, responses and final submission; we do not promise publication or alter findings.

Explore journal publication support